The world of westerns is full of stereotypes. Rowdy, dangerous saloons, women destined for the brothel, ruthless “Indians,” and brave Rangers. Close your eyes and you can already picture smoking guns, spooked horses, scalps taken as trophies. I’m here to tell you this genre is so much more than that. Sure, there’s no shortage of duels, or young men chasing gold and fortune. But there’s a lot more going on too.
There are women braver than the men around them, yet doomed from the start in a man’s world that uses them and throws them away. There are nostalgic gunslingers who hate violence and are still condemned — in their own way — to repeat the same actions over and over. And there are sheriffs of towns forgotten by everyone, trying to do right, trying to find justice, in a world that mostly makes up its own rules as it goes.
Here are 3 books to read if you want to understand the genre better and forget every stereotype you had about it.
Warlock by Oakley Hall
Set in a frontier mining town in the late 1800s, among miners, cowboys, and a private sheriff hired by a fed-up citizenry, this isn’t a book for beginners. There are subtleties here, details to catch, things left unsaid, characters who embody the ideals of the American Wild West. Considered a “revisionist” western, published in 1958 and a Pulitzer finalist, Warlock is often cited as a precursor to McCarthy’s Blood Meridian (which I still haven’t read). Some chapters are written as diary entries from one of the townspeople, which shifts the rhythm of the narrative in an interesting way.
The result is a choral, almost philosophical western: sure, there are duels, sunlight glinting off rifle barrels, but what really stays with you is the question of what justice even means once the official rules stop being enough. This book proves westerns aren’t just dusty shootouts and hard men glaring at each other; they can be a mental chess match where nobody wants to give in, nobody wants to lose. If you like a western that makes you think as much as it keeps you on the edge of your seat, Warlock is the right place to start. Fair warning, though: it takes patience. This isn’t a fast read.
The Homesman by Glendon Swarthout
This novel completely flips the conventions of a historically male-dominated, stereotype-heavy genre. And it’s not pure fiction or an invented epic, either. Swarthout’s novel rests on solid historical ground, telling the brutal truth about pioneer life in 1850s Nebraska.
The extraordinary strength of The Homesman lies in how convincingly it pulls you in. I walked through the mud and the cold right alongside these characters, completely absorbed into this group of women broken by the inhuman harshness of the frontier. Mary Bee Cuddy (an indomitable, resourceful “spinster”) takes on the thankless job of escorting four women east, women driven literally mad by loneliness, the loss of their children, and the brutal winters. Swarthout doesn’t sugarcoat anything: I felt their suffering on my own skin, the weight of a geographic and mental isolation that official history has always preferred to look away from.
And then there’s him: George Briggs, the homesman who gives the book its title. He’s a washed-up old drifter, a con man Mary Bee saves from the noose, who ends up acting as her bodyguard in exchange for money. Briggs is a magnificent character in his own wretchedness: a man with no salvation, no prospects, no smiles left to give. A true anti-hero of the West, standing in stark contrast to soldiers, sheriffs, and Rangers.
Lonesome Dove by Larry McMurtry
If you only ever read one western in your life, most people will tell you it should be this one. Winner of the Pulitzer Prize in 1986, Lonesome Dove follows two aging former Texas Rangers, Augustus McCrae and Woodrow Call, as they drive a herd of cattle from the dusty little border town of Lonesome Dove all the way up to Montana. It sounds simple enough on paper. It isn’t. Along the way, McMurtry fits in an entire world: outlaws, lost loves, quiet tragedies, and a cast of characters who feel less like archetypes and more like people you’ve actually known.
What makes Lonesome Dove so beloved is the Gus and Call duo, the true heart of the book. They are two old friends who’ve spent a lifetime side by side and still see the world in completely different ways. It’s a big, sprawling epic, but never a cold one — underneath all the cattle drives and gunfights, it’s really a book about growing old, about friendship, and about the cost of a life spent chasing the horizon.
It’s the western that even people who think they hate westerns tend to fall for. Consider yourself warned: once you start, it’s hard to put down.
Bonus: westerns to add to your (and my) TBR
- The Revenant by Michael Punke
- The Big Sky by A. B. Guthrie
- Blood Meridian by Cormac McCarthy
- The Ruthless by Claudia Ravens
- Diezmo by Rick Bass.
Funny enough, that’s actually the very saga I was just gushing about above. I first read Lonesome Dove two years ago, and now, with the whole series sitting on my shelf, I’m about to start a reread — this time in chronological order. Will I love it as much as the first time around?
Leave a Reply